What is an AI identity, really?

Brian Davis
January 08, 2026

It’s tempting to answer this quickly.

An API key.
A service account.
A set of permissions.
A non-human identity.

That’s usually where the conversation stops.

But if you slow down, the idea starts to stretch.

An identity, at its simplest, is something we recognize.
Something we can point to and say: this is who acted.

Humans have names.
Roles.
Histories.
Patterns.

Over time, those patterns become familiar.
Predictable.
Legible.

AI identities don’t arrive with that kind of texture.

They arrive as capabilities.

A model that can approve a transaction.
An agent that can reset an account.
A system that can decide, route, deny, escalate.

At first, it feels clean.

The AI “did the work.”
The system “made the call.”
The decision “followed policy.”

But sit with it a little longer and the edges blur.

Who is the AI acting as?

The engineer who configured it?
The team that trained it?
The policy it was mapped to?
The organization that benefits from its decisions?

Or is the identity something else entirely.

Not a who.
A where.

A place where intent, automation, and accountability briefly overlap.

This is where AI identities start to feel different.

They don’t accumulate reputation the way people do.
They don’t develop instincts.
They don’t hesitate.

They execute.

And because they execute consistently, we start trusting them.
Because we trust them, we give them more authority.
And because they don’t complain, we rarely notice when their “identity” quietly expands.

Until something goes wrong.

That’s usually the moment someone asks the question out loud:

“Who made this decision?”

And the room gets quiet.

Because the answer isn’t obvious anymore.
Not because no one is responsible.
But because responsibility has been distributed so efficiently that it no longer looks like ownership.

Maybe an AI identity isn’t defined by credentials or controls.

Maybe it’s defined by the moment we realize we can’t clearly explain why it acted the way it did.
Or who is expected to stand behind the outcome.

That might be the real signal.

Not when the system works.
But when its actions force us to decide whether we recognize it as ours.

Let’s not stop asking why.

What is an AI identity, really?

Subscribe to keep reading

Keep Reading

Join 4,500+people who can’t stop asking why.

Join 4,500+people
who can’t stop asking why.